[Bug] minimax-music-gen requires retired mmx music commands
Summary
The minimax-music-gen skill currently instructs agents to run mmx music generate, but current mmx-cli releases no longer expose any music resource. As a result, a fresh installation of the official skill and its documented prerequisite cannot generate music.
Reproduction
npx skills add minimax-ai/skills@minimax-music-gen -y
npm install -g mmx-cli
mmx --version
# mmx 1.0.24
mmx music generate \
--instrumental \
--prompt "Instrumental R&B background music" \
--quiet --non-interactive --dry-runActual result:
{
"error": {
"code": 2,
"message": "Unknown command: mmx music generate Instrumental R&B background music",
"hint": "mmx --help"
}
}mmx --help lists text, speech, image, video, search, vision, quota, config, file, etc., but not music. The same absence is present in [email protected].
Root cause / upstream context
Music support was intentionally removed from the CLI and SDK in MiniMax-AI/cli#239 because the corresponding Music APIs were being sunset:
- https://github.com/MiniMax-AI/cli/pull/239
- Removal commit: https://github.com/MiniMax-AI/cli/commit/1b53953ebff127fc980b088f995661aac2c844db
The last npm CLI release that still exposes mmx music generate appears to be [email protected]. However, pinning that old CLI does not seem like a safe long-term workaround because it targets APIs that upstream explicitly says are being sunset.
The skill still documents mmx music generate, mmx music cover, music-2.6-free, and music-cover-free, so its current workflow conflicts with the supported CLI surface.
Expected behavior
A freshly installed official skill should either:
- use a currently supported MiniMax music-generation API/tool, or
- clearly mark the skill as unavailable/retired and stop instructing agents to install
mmx-cliand invoke removed commands.
Suggested fix
- If a replacement MiniMax music endpoint/tool exists, migrate the skill to it and add a tested version/compatibility check.
- Otherwise, deprecate/archive
minimax-music-gen(and any dependent playlist/buddy music skills) so agents do not route music requests to a guaranteedUnknown commandfailure. - Avoid recommending
[email protected]unless the retired endpoints are explicitly confirmed to remain supported.
Environment
minimax-ai/skillsmain branch,skills/minimax-music-gen/SKILL.md[email protected](npmlatestduring reproduction)- Also checked
[email protected]: no music resource - Node.js 24, Windows 11
Source: MiniMax-AI/skills