Open question: Web UI theming / community themes
Proposed addition to direction.md under ## Open questions (no stance yet):
UI theming. The Web UI ships a single hardcoded dark theme (
packages/web/src/index.css) with no extension seam — no theme registry, no user-overridable tokens, no plugin/marketplace path. Whether Archon should support theming, and at what scope, is undecided:
- (a) Single-org branding — a user-overridable CSS-custom-property file so a self-hosted install can match brand colors. Small: no plugin contract needed, just a config-level override point.
- (b) Community theme marketplace — shareable, installable themes distributed like provider/platform plugins. Larger: needs a declarative token registry, a marketplace listing kind, and a trust-boundary decision (plain data/tokens only, vs. arbitrary CSS/JS injection).
Unlike provider/platform/forge plugins (
§community-plugins), a theme is static data, not a runtime contract — it may not need the "attach without branches in engine control flow" plugin machinery at all.Settle before any implementation:
- Is demand real and does it favor (a) or (b)? No reported requests yet — possible hypothesis is that design-conscious/brand-sensitive orgs self-hosting Archon want tooling to match brand identity, but this is unconfirmed and shouldn't be assumed. Don't build (b) to solve (a).
- Does this jump the queue ahead of
§community-plugins's stated sequencing ("forge contract goes first, followed by chat/platform and provider contracts")?- Is a theme seam premature given the console/Web UI's own shape is still unsettled (
§web-ui: workflow-authoring UI remains an open experiment)?- If (b): what's the minimal themeable token surface (only variables with genuine demonstrated variance, per the spirit of
§schema-width), and what's the trust boundary for community-submitted styling?
Cited clauses: §community-plugins, §web-ui, §schema-width (by analogy).
Ask of maintainers: decide whether this becomes a tracked open question in direction.md, gets declined outright (with a cited clause), or is folded into an existing tracked issue (e.g. #2791 standalone-core work, if theming is judged in-scope there).
cc @coleam00 @Wirasm
Source: coleam00/Archon