#11731·social-app

Self-repost of an own post leaves the author's reply orphaned in the profile feed

Author: etimc91Created Sep 16, 2026Updated Sep 16, 2026
Labelsbug

Steps to Reproduce

Describe the bug

When I repost one of my own posts that I have also replied to, the original post is correctly surfaced at the top of my profile feed (via the new repost). The reply I left on that post stays in its original chronological position.

The result is an “orphan” reply in the profile feed: a post that only says it is a reply to me, with no parent visible nearby. The thread context is broken for anyone scrolling the profile.

This is especially visible on the Posts tab of a profile when the author both replies to and later reposts the same root post.

To Reproduce

Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Create a post on your own account (post A).
  2. Reply to post A from the same account (reply B).
  3. Later, repost post A from the same account.
  4. Open your own profile → Posts tab.
  5. Observe:
    • Post A appears near the top, as a self-repost.
    • Reply B remains lower in the feed, still labeled as a reply, without post A next to it.

Expected behavior

After a self-repost of a post that already has my own reply:

  • Either the reply is grouped with / attached to the surfaced parent (so the thread stays readable).
  • Or the orphan reply is not shown as a standalone item on the profile Posts tab when the parent has just been bumped by a self-repost.

Ideal UX: the profile feed should not show a reply “to you” with no visible parent in the same viewport.

Screenshots

[Attach the screenshot of orphan replies — the ones labeled “Replying to you” sitting alone in the feed while the parent has been bumped to the top.]

The screenshot shows several consecutive author replies with no parent post immediately above them. That is the “orphan reply” state.

Platform

  • App: Bluesky official client
  • OS: Android (also please check iOS / Web)
  • Version: latest from Play Store at time of report

Additional context

This is a profile-feed / author-feed presentation issue, not a protocol issue. The records are correct (app.bsky.feed.post + app.bsky.feed.repost). The client’s author feed (getAuthorFeed, default posts_with_replies) treats the reply as an independent timeline item and does not re-associate it when the parent is re-surfaced by a self-repost.

Related feed filters that may be involved:

  • posts_with_replies (default on profile Posts)
  • posts_and_author_threads

Possible directions:

  • Collapse author replies into the parent thread item when the parent is also in the same author feed window.
  • Hide standalone author replies whose parent was just self-reposted and is already shown higher in the same feed.
  • Prefer posts_and_author_threads grouping on the profile Posts tab so self-replies stay attached to their root.

Attachments

130451.jpg

What platform(s) does this occur on?

Android

Device Info

Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra

What version of the app are you using?

1.132.0

Additional Information

No response

Source: bluesky-social/social-app